Cross-border ecommerce (CBEC) lets a foreign brand sell into China with no Chinese company and no product registration, in its home-country pack, and it taxes each unit less. General trade costs months of paperwork, then opens stores and wholesale. At our calculator’s defaults, the cheaper route flips at roughly 1,900 to 7,100 units a month.
That flip may run the other way from what you expect. Below it, selling ex-works to a general trade importer leaves you more per unit, because the importer and the retailers carry the freight, the warehouse, the traffic and the price. Above it, your own cross-border store wins, because its fixed fees get spread thin and the tax break keeps working on every order.
So treat the route as a volume question, and expect the answer to move as your sales do.
The two routes differ on fourteen operational lines. Here they are, checked against the Chinese texts on November 21, 2026.
| Line | Cross-border ecommerce | General trade import | What decides it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chinese legal entity | None. Your overseas company sells; a domestic agent files with customs | A Chinese importer of record, yours or a partner’s | Whether you want to own a company in China |
| Product registration and licences | No first-import permit, registration or filing, with exceptions for quarantine and high-risk goods | Your category’s rules apply in full: food importer filing, plant registration, cosmetics filing | Your category |
| Chinese physical label | Not required. The shopper sees a risk notice and a Chinese e-label online | Required on every pack before the goods enter | Whether you can run a China-only pack |
| Duty and tax | 0% duty; VAT and consumption tax at 70%, so 9.1% for general goods; the shopper is the taxpayer | Duty on the landed value, then 13% import VAT, credited down the chain | Price per unit |
| Purchase limits | 5,000 RMB an order and 26,000 RMB a year per shopper | None | Your price point and how much a loyal buyer spends |
| Positive list | Your tariff line must be on the 1,476-line list; 204 lines are bonded-stock only | Any product China admits | Your 8-digit HS code |
| Inventory location and refills | A bonded warehouse in a special customs zone (code 1210), or parcels shipped from abroad (9610) | Duty-paid stock in the importer’s or distributor’s warehouses | Where your buyers are and how fast you sell through |
| Minimum cash to start | Set by you: our calculator’s bonded deposit and tax prepayment total 400,000 RMB | Set by the importer’s first order, which has to fill its own channels | Your balance sheet |
| Offline sales | Not allowed. Bonded pickup outside the zone is barred in principle | Allowed | Whether stores matter in your category |
| Sales to other retailers | Not allowed. Goods are for the shopper’s own use and can’t be resold | Allowed | Whether you need distributors |
| VAT invoicing | Tax collected per order at the border, withheld by the platform or logistics firm | Every seller charges VAT, credits what it paid and issues a fapiao | Whether your buyers are companies |
| Returns | Apply within 30 days of release; goods back in the zone within 45 | Handled by the domestic seller like any local return | Your return rate |
| Price control | You own the goods and set the listed price | The chain sets the shelf price; the Anti-Monopoly Law restricts fixing a reseller’s price | How much the price matters to your brand abroad |
| Time to first sale | As soon as the store is approved and stock lands in the zone | After registrations, Chinese labels and an importer contract | Your launch date |
Sources for the tax, limit, list and returns rows follow in the sections below, each checked on November 21, 2026.
What cross-border actually exempts you from, and what it doesn’t
The exemption is real and it is written down. A 2018 notice from six ministries put cross-border retail imports under the rules for goods a person brings in for personal use.
Cross-border retail imports are supervised as personal-use goods and are exempt from first-import permits, registration and filing requirements. Source: Ministry of Commerce and five other bodies (商务部等六部门), 商财发〔2018〕486号, November 2018. https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2018-12/31/content_5437823.htm
That one sentence is why a French skincare brand can list on Tmall Global, the cross-border marketplace run by Alibaba, without filing its formulas in China. The same notice carves out goods under quarantine control or with a major quality risk, so the exemption isn’t absolute for every category.
The tax side comes from a 2016 circular.
Within the limits, the duty rate on cross-border retail imports is 0%, and import VAT and consumption tax are collected at 70% of the statutory amount. The shopper is the taxpayer; the platform, the seller or the logistics company may collect it. Source: Ministry of Finance (财政部), 财关税〔2016〕18号, March 2016. http://www.mof.gov.cn/gp/xxgkml/gss/201603/t20160324_2510682.htm
Imported goods carry 13% VAT. Import VAT is levied on the dutiable value plus duty and consumption tax, and a seller deducts the input VAT it paid. Source: State Taxation Administration (国家税务总局), VAT Law of the People’s Republic of China, in force January 1, 2026. https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/zcfgk/c100009/c5237365/content.html
Thirteen percent times 70% is 9.1%. On a 250 RMB order, all in, the shopper pays 20.85 RMB of tax cross-border. The same 250 RMB on a supermarket shelf holds 28.76 RMB of VAT, before any duty. Inside the limits, cross-border is cheaper per unit on tax at every volume.
Now the limits.
The cap is 5,000 RMB per transaction and 26,000 RMB per shopper per year, from January 1, 2019. A single item above 5,000 RMB but inside the annual cap pays duty, VAT and consumption tax in full and counts toward the year. Spending above the annual cap is handled as general trade. Source: Ministry of Finance, General Administration of Customs and State Taxation Administration (财政部 海关总署 税务总局), 财关税〔2018〕49号, November 2018. https://fgk.chinatax.gov.cn/zcfgk/c102416/c5202372/content.html
Returns run on a customs clock.
A cross-border return must be applied for within 30 days of the release of the declaration, and the goods must be back in the original customs zone or bonded center within 45 days. Source: General Administration of Customs (海关总署), Announcement 2020 No. 45, March 2020. https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2020-03/28/content_5496571.htm
What the exemption doesn’t buy you is reach. The 2018 notice limits purchases to the shopper’s own use, bans resale, and in principle bars “bonded online order, offline pickup” outside special customs zones. That rules out the supermarket shelf, and it rules out the distributor. Your overseas company is also the owner of the goods and carries the quality and recall liability, and it has to appoint a company registered in China to declare to customs and share that liability. Our guide to setting up a cross-border store walks through who fills each of those roles.
The positive list, and how to check your own HS code
Cross-border only works for products on a list of tariff lines kept by the Ministry of Finance and the agencies that co-sign it. The current edition is the 2019 list as adjusted from March 1, 2022.
The 2022 adjustment added 29 lines, including ski gear, household dishwashers and tomato juice, and removed one (knives and swords), taking the list to 1,476 lines. Source: China Daily (中国日报网), February 2022. https://cn.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202202/23/WS6215f75ba3107be497a077a6.html
The adjustment took effect on March 1, 2022, issued by eight bodies led by the Ministry of Finance. Source: Ministry of Finance and seven other bodies (财政部等8部门), Announcement 2022 No. 7, on the Chinese government portal, February 2022. https://www.gov.cn/zhengce/zhengceku/2022-02/21/content_5674854.htm
China’s customs service created two codes for this trade in 2014: 9610 for cross-border e-commerce and 1210 for bonded cross-border e-commerce. Source: Jiaxiang County Commerce Bureau (嘉祥县商务局), January 2024. http://jiaxiang.gov.cn/art/2024/1/17/art_72008_2758261.html
The remarks column matters as much as the code. In the list our China cross-border check loads, 204 of the 1,476 lines are marked bonded stock only (仅限网购保税商品). Those products can sell cross-border from a bonded warehouse in China but not as parcels mailed from abroad. Other remarks exclude endangered species, medical devices and goods on banned-import lists.
Checking takes three steps:
- Get the 8-digit Chinese tariff code from your freight forwarder or customs broker. Your home country’s code shares only the first six digits.
- Find the exact 8-digit line on the list, then read its remark.
- If only a sibling line under the same six digits is listed, ask your broker which line customs will apply before you plan stock.
A product off the list has one road into China. General trade.
What general trade costs before you sell a single unit
The work, mostly. General trade asks for everything cross-border waived, and the bill depends on your category and on who does the work.
Someone in China has to import. That is your own subsidiary or an importer that already holds the licences. For food, the law names the steps.
Overseas exporters and food importers must file with the inspection authority, overseas producers must be registered, and imported prepackaged food must carry a Chinese label naming the origin and the domestic agent, or it may not be imported. Source: Ministry of Commerce policy database (商务部), Food Safety Law (食品安全法), articles 96 and 97, as amended September 2025. https://policy.mofcom.gov.cn/claw/clawContent.shtml?id=104105
Cosmetics take a different path to the same place.
An overseas cosmetics filer must appoint a Chinese enterprise as domestic responsible person, which files in the brand’s name and carries quality and safety liability for products on the Chinese market. Source: State Administration for Market Regulation (市场监管总局), Measures for Cosmetics Registration and Filing, Order No. 35, January 2021. https://www.gov.cn/gongbao/content/2021/content_5595926.htm
Then a Chinese label printed for every pack, which usually means a China-only production run. Then duty at your line’s rate on the landed value, and 13% VAT at the border. That VAT gets credited down the chain, so it’s cash flow for the importer rather than a cost, but the shopper still pays the full 13% inside the shelf price.
We don’t print a price for this setup. We found no dated, primary figure for it, and it swings by category: a shelf-stable sauce with an existing importer is a label job, while a new skincare line is a filing project. Treat it as months and a quote, and put the quote into the model below.
CBEC vs general trade: the volume where the math flips
This is our number. We ran both routes at the same shopper price through the defaults of our Tmall Global setup and running cost calculator.
The cross-border side is your own Tmall Global store run by a Tmall Partner (TP), the agency that operates it. You keep the listed price and pay the platform, the partner, the media and the parcels. The general trade side is an importer buying ex-works, with the price backed out of the same shelf price through the margins in our worked distributor margin and shelf price ladder. You invoice and the chain pays for everything after your dock.
| Category (Tmall Global commission, annual fee) | Units a month, duty 0% | Duty 5% | Duty 10% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Packaged food (2%, 30,000 RMB) | 3,027 | 2,284 | 1,865 |
| Skincare (4%, 30,000 RMB) | 4,753 | 3,146 | 2,403 |
| Apparel (5%, 60,000 RMB) | 7,084 | 4,132 | 2,991 |
TheChinaPath modeling, November 2026, from TheChinaPath calculator data. Below each figure, general trade through an importer leaves the brand more per unit. Above it, the cross-border store does. In sales terms the range runs from about 470,000 to 1.8 million RMB a month (roughly $66,000 to $250,000 at the calculator’s rate of 7.1 RMB to the dollar).
The inputs, so you can argue with them:
- Shopper price 250 RMB all in, one unit per order (the calculator’s default order value). Cross-border tax 9.1%, carried by the shopper.
- Cross-border store, per order: platform commission by category, payment 1%, partner commission 10%, paid media at 60% of sales and a return on ad spend of 2, creators on 20% of sales at 20%, pick and pack 4 RMB, last mile 11 RMB, 5% returns at 15 RMB, storage 0.8 RMB.
- Cross-border store, fixed: partner retainer 35,000 RMB a month, the category’s annual fee, 25,000 RMB of setup written off over three years.
- General trade, backed out of the 250 RMB shelf: 13% VAT, retailer margin 30%, distributor 20%, importer 20%, sea freight 12.5% and port costs 8.3% of ex-works. These margins are illustration, the same ones our ladder uses.
- Same sea freight on both sides; the brand pays it cross-border, the importer pays it in general trade.
At 0% duty the importer pays about 82 RMB ex-works for a unit that sells at 250. The cross-border store keeps about 95 RMB a unit for food, 90 for skincare and 88 for apparel before its fixed fees. A gap of 6 to 13 RMB a unit has to carry 38,000 to 41,000 RMB a month of retainer, annual fee and setup. That’s why the flip sits in the thousands.
Higher duty pulls the flip down, because duty comes out of the importer’s landed cost and so out of your ex-works price, while cross-border pays none. A better return on ad spend pulls it down too. Apparel returns run far above the 5% default, and every extra return pushes the apparel flip higher. Any setup cost general trade puts on your side, a filing or a label run, pulls the flip lower.
The model covers Tmall Global only. JD Worldwide and Douyin cross-border stores charge different deposits and commissions, so run their own calculators before you borrow these figures.
One more line sits outside the per-unit math: cash. The calculator holds 100,000 RMB as a bonded warehouse deposit and 300,000 RMB as a tax prepayment before the first order, on top of the platform’s own deposit.
The hybrid, and why brands drift into it
Some brands end up running both. Cross-border carries the full range and the new launches. General trade carries the three or four lines that sell in volume and belong on a shelf.
The logic falls out of the table. Cross-border tests demand with no filing. The products that clear the flip, or that need stores and distributors, earn the work of general trade. And anything above 26,000 RMB a year per buyer, or off the positive list, never had a choice.
The friction is price. Two routes put two prices in front of the same shopper, and the general trade shelf price isn’t yours to fix.
An operator may not agree with a trading counterparty to fix the resale price to a third party or set a minimum resale price, unless it proves the agreement doesn’t restrict competition or meets the market-share safe harbor. Source: Ministry of Commerce policy database (商务部), Anti-Monopoly Law (反垄断法), article 18, as amended June 2022. https://policy.mofcom.gov.cn/claw/clawContent.shtml?id=97047
So the levers are structural. Keep the SKUs apart (different pack sizes, a China label only on the general trade version), and tell your distribution partners which lines are theirs.
How to decide this month rather than next quarter
Four checks settle it, in this order.
Your HS code first. Off the list, or bonded-only when you wanted direct mail, and the decision is made for you.
Then your price. A unit above 5,000 RMB loses the tax break; a buyer who spends more than 26,000 RMB a year falls out of the channel.
Then your channel. If the plan needs supermarkets, pharmacies, hotels or distributors, cross-border can’t carry it, whatever the tax says.
Then your volume. Put your own order value, margins and category into the calculator and compare the result against the ex-works price an importer offers you. If your honest monthly forecast sits below the flip, general trade through a good importer is the cheaper start. If it sits well above, your own store leaves you more on every unit.
Frequently asked questions
Is cross-border cheaper than general trade in China?
On tax, yes. Within the limits it pays 0% duty and 70% of VAT, 9.1% for general goods, against 13% VAT plus duty. On total cost to the brand it depends on volume: at our calculator’s defaults, an importer leaves you more per unit below roughly 1,900 to 7,100 units a month.
Do I need a Chinese company to sell cross-border?
No. Your overseas company sells and owns the goods. You do need a company registered in China to file with customs as your agent, and it shares civil liability for the declarations. On Tmall Global the clearance firm or warehouse your Tmall Partner works with often fills that role.
Can cross-border products be sold in shops in China?
No. The 2018 notice limits cross-border goods to the shopper’s own use and bans resale, and in principle bars offline pickup of bonded orders outside special customs zones. To sell in shops, the goods have to come in under general trade, with Chinese labels and the registrations your category needs.
How do I know if my product is on the positive list?
Get the 8-digit Chinese tariff code from your broker, then find that exact line on the 2019 list as adjusted in 2022, which runs to 1,476 lines. Read the remark as well: 204 lines are restricted to bonded stock. Our China cross-border check reads your code against the list for you.
Run the first-year calculator for your category under both routes
Updated November 23, 2026
Working on China? Let's grab a coffee.
Tell us where you are now and where you want to get to.




